Let’s Talk About Tomb Raider

Megan Patterson February 28, 2013 6

Tomb Raider Screenshot 02

The new Tomb Raider prequel is set to come out next Tuesday, and with the release date so close, a lot of information has started to come out about the game that we didn’t have before. The game has been mired in a bit of scandal since last year’s E3, when studio heads claimed there was a rape scene in the game, then that there wasn’t, and then that there is. (It was very confusing.) Early testers of the game also said it fostered a sense of protectiveness for Lara, and a lot of feminists (myself included), have been upset that the game has dumbed down one of gaming’s only iconic female characters. Not to mention the fact that rape is a horrible (and lazy) way to make a game “dark” and “edgy.”

Since last year, Crystal Dynamics has brought on Rhianna Pratchett (Terry Pratchett’s daughter) as lead writer, and I wouldn’t be surprised if the sexual assault was taken out of the final game entirely. Screenshots of the game have been pretty impressive, and now that I know more about the game play, I can say that I actually might want to play this game. There’s still a lot that could be problematic, but I do think it looks like Square Enix and Crystal Dynamics have done a very good job at making a game that I want to play. Let’s take a look at one of the “Guide to Survival” videos that details the combat and mechanics of the game.

I have to say, it’s a beautiful-looking game, aesthetics-wise. And I like the choice you have in your play style, and the choice you have in weapons, and the Assassin’s Creed-esque stealth and climbing mechanics. I like Lara’s redesign, because she looks like a normal human being. But holy crap, this game is not easy on her AT ALL. It is a very violent game, even for a video game, and I think especially for a Tomb Raider title. I can’t help but feel that because Lara is a woman, and because they want to be “edgy,” that a lot more horrible things and violent acts are going to happen to her, and I’m not sure how I feel about that. Like, this game looks like it is brutal on her, in a way that I don’t see with male characters.

Early reviews for the game have been overall pretty positive. I would be lying if I said I wasn’t curious to find out for myself what the deal is with this game, and the game mechanics make it something that I would play. Tomb Raider is being released on March 5th for Xbox and PS3.

Do you think you’ll find yourself picking this one up?

  • http://something-geeky.tumblr.com/ Vanessa Di Gregorio

    I have to admit, I do kinda want to play this. It looks incredible!

    I really hope that rape scene is gone, though I agree that Lara will most likely go through a violence different from those in games with male protagonists. But, as women, I think we do live in fear of a different violence than men do.

    It’s weird, because on the one hand I think that acknowledging the dangers we face as women is important. But I also think it will make a strong female icon weaker in the eyes of many. And I’m not worried it will glorify rape or sexual assault, but I do worry that it won’t capture the truth of it either. And the men who play it will react differently than the women playing it.

    As a gamer, I’m hoping that I’m wrong and that there is very little sexual violence. I’d rather gamers see Lara not as a woman, per se, but as an individual who is strong and capable. I’d rather she face dangers that male protagonists would face, and that the story doesn’t focus on her womanhood as much – because that’s where things can go very wrong.

    Bah, I feel like I made no sense.

    • http://twitter.com/mk_patter Megasus

      No totally, but she gets the absolute SHIT beaten out of her in this game, in a way that I don’t think I’ve ever seen in a game with a male protagonist, if that makes any sense. It’s almost as if she HAS to go through the wringer, so that she won’t be seen as weak or something. I’m not entirely sure if that’s the reason, but it does make me a bit uncomfortable and wary.

    • StephFurlan

      I think you explained yourself really well, Vanessa! It would be nice if gaming companies actually accepted some feedback from female gamers or had more female writers on the team. I really do hope they took out the rape scene. I think they should consider that if they’re not going to something to a male character then they shouldn’t do it to a female character.

      • http://twitter.com/mk_patter Megasus

        It’s true! I have NEVER played a game with a rape scene with a male character, so why is it acceptable to do it to a female one?

    • http://twitter.com/lyssness Alyssa

      I love this and totally second everything you said, Vanessa! I think this whole situation just further illustrates why we need more women in the gaming industry. I’m optimistic about the fact that Rhianna Pratchett has had some say in the game’s development, and I sincerely hope the final result is not focus on Lara as a woman but on Lara as a strong protagonist.

  • arielletje

    My interest is definitely piqued by Rhianna Pratchett being on board. Hopefully there will at least be a good narrative reason for everything that happens to Lara, as opposed to the usual “Because it’s coooool”. I mean, sure, doing something because it’s cool is super fun, but it’s a very subjective definition that can get you into trouble. Let’s hope they keep Lara out of it.