For Your Review: K.D. Reads Recommended Fantasy

K. D. Callaghan October 1, 2012 6

First in a new series of articles on classic fantasy and science fiction, read and reviewed by Paper Droids’ KD Callaghan. I’m sure we can all relate to the fact that, after mentioning that I love fantasy literature, there inevitably follows a barrage of questions and recommendations about classics of the genre from whoever else is in the conversation, partly to test your geek cred, and partly to suss out any shared fandoms. KD’s been given a list, and for the next few weeks we’re going to follow her on her adventures through fantasy literature: I for one am super excited. Let’s take a look at what’s in store! -Ariel Kroon, Art and Lit editor

Thanks, Ariel! Like any dedicated reader I have a huge to-be-read list. (Actually, I have an Excel Spreadsheet, but that’s beside the point). And since school has left me way behind, I feel like I’m perpetually under-read, so this is me, catching up on some of the most interesting looking—and most highly recommended—books on my TBR list.

Daughter of Exile by Isabel Glass

I came across this one while doing research for a project for a creative writing class. I kept seeing it described as “literary fantasy” which intrigued me, because there very much seems to be a divide between “literature” and fantasy which my professors encouraged and which I was working to break down in that class.

What am I expecting? From the blurb and my research, I’m expecting an epic fantasy adventure that’s more “literary”: more image systems, more overt themes, and probably a more obvious commentary on some real world issues. ***Review here

 

The Mistborn trilogy by Brandon Sanderson

This series was recommended to me by a Master’s student studying fantasy lit because a) it was excellent and b) it apparently has a very similar premise to the novel I am currently working on.

What am I expecting? From such glowing reviews I’m expecting something genre-shifting—in the form of a tale of rebellion that plays with the prophecy trope and looks at what happens to a people after a prophecy has failed. ***Review here

 

 

 Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell by Susanna Clarke

I have seen this book literally everywhere and it piqued my curiosity. I did some digging and found out that it won the Hugo award in 2005 and was a contender for the Man Booker prize in 2004, which has only made me want to read it more.

What am I expecting? Victorian England + magic = a finely crafted, suspenseful tale which revolves around the relationship between Jonathan Strange and Mr. Norrell. ***Review here

 

 

The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake by Aimee Bender

One of my creative writing professors name-dropped Aimee Bender when we were talking about surrealism in class and later referenced Particular Sadness in a discussion on magic realism, which has me very interested.

What am I expecting? A strange and wonderful story about family that puts the magic realism perfected by writers like Gabriel Garcia Marquez and Salman Rushdie into a more North American context. I also get the feeling that I’m going to be very hungry reading this book. ***Review here

 

The Icewind Dale Trilogy by R. A. Salvatore

One of the girls I used to work with recommended this series to me, saying “Artemis Entreri will be your new favourite character. I guarantee it.” Since we have fairly similar taste in books and in characters I’m intrigued to see what she’s talking about.

What am I expecting? To be completely captivated by Entreri when he comes along eventually, and to otherwise just enjoy what looks like a rollicking good adventure series. ***Review here

  • Pingback: Paper Droids – For Your Review: The Particular Sadness of Lemon Cake

  • Trista

    I used to adore R.A. Salvatore when I was a teenager, and then a few years ago I decided to reread my favourite trilogy of his, the Dark Elf Trilogy centered around the background of his most famous character, Drizz’t Do’Urden.

    I was so very, very, very disappointed. It’s not terrible? But it’s not good by any stretch of the imagination. Everyone is Very Evil except for the hero, to the point where he’s able to defy his race’s shortcomings by his sheer power of Goodness. (Like enjoying the sun and thinking it’s so pure and good while all the other drow elves wince in pain. It’s like a vampire enjoying a sunbath, only with less dying.) Time passes by like “and then five years went by and he was an awesome fighter”.

    That series is the prequel to the Icewind Dale Trilogy, which I’ve yet to reread (and also remember loving) but think would be a lot better, if only because it has several heroes and doesn’t take place in a completely evil world with one sole good guy.

  • Nikita Shah

    I’m 98% finished with Jonathan Strange & Mr. Norrell. It’s on my list of favourites, it’s so wonderfully written, I just don’t want it to end (which is why I’m taking my time).

  • http://gigglesnfarts.tumblr.com Cate

    Oooooh Lemon Cake is one of my favorite books of all time. Love Aimee Bender!

    Jonathan Strange was not my cup of tea, but I think I am in the minority there. :)

    Are you going to check back in once you’ve read them and talk about expectations vs reality?

    • http://kdcallag.wordpress.com/ K. D. Callaghan

      I’m absolutely going to be following up this list with reviews, Cate! I’m starting with of Daughter of Exile. That review should be out next week. :)

  • http://dianahurlburt.wordpress.com DianaH

    Ooh! I think I will like this new series. Most of what I read is fantasy of some kind. I’ve seen Daughter of Exile a couple of times at the library…maybe I will pick it up too!