Dear 300, I Hate You

Ariel Kroon September 22, 2012 8

I will never get those two hours of my life back.

Before you say anything: I have not read the graphic novel. I’ve heard all about how the movie was based on it; there’s an aesthetic, it’s a work of literature made of pure gold shat out the miraculous colon of a magical unicorn etc etc. I know. I was going to read it, and then I saw the movie in theatres, and now I really have no desire to even be in the same room as it because 300 was probably one of the worst films I’ve ever seen. Allow me to expand…

1. It’s American war propaganda

In which the fair, upright, and just men of the west go to war against the dark, encroaching eastern threat, though the odds are overwhelming, because Good must always stand against Evil. Sound familiar? Probably because it totally is, and while I love LotR dearly, this is one thing that makes me dry heave, not least because if you scrape off the thin pretense of civility, this is what a lot of actual political rhetoric came down to back in the mid-00s.

  •   1a: I cannot even articulate how racist it is to paint an entire civilization as monstrous, greedy, warmongering deformities. 300 depicts the Persian army as LITERALLY inhuman, just in case you had a moment where you might have almost related to one of them.

2. Hard luck if you’re not an able-bodied white dude.

  • Guess who’s a traitor? Is it the craven, malicious-looking hunchback with all the worst lines? CORRECT, ZERO POINTS TO GRYFFINDOR.
  • Are you the most powerful woman in the city-state? Oop, too bad, you still get raped. Don’t worry, the movie will make it creepily sexual during and you get revenge after, so it’s sort of okay. Right?
  • How about the only other woman in the movie? Haha, joke’s on you, slut – you’re only there to provide fetish fuel and move the plot (minutely) along. You don’t really even have a self.
  • If you’re an old guy, don’t even bother; anything that comes out of your mouth is moronic and obsolete because you’re SO OLD UGH.

3. Homophobia is the name of the game

Pff, those Athenians with their democracy and culture and penchant for little boys. Never mind that Spartans were historically homosexual as well. There are too many jokes to be made about the oiled wall of rippling manflesh the camera so lovingly panned over for most of the group scenes in 300 even while the rhetoric of the movie was very anti-gay, to the point where there’s a (moronic, unnecessary) couple of throwaway lines about how Sparta’s not to be outdone by a bunch of pansy intellectuals. Hurr hurr boylovers, amirite?

4. Everything is a super-dramatic ultimatum

To the point where I completely stopped caring.

“Choose your next words carefully, Leonidas. They may be your last as king.”
“Come back with your shield, or on it.”
“Our arrows will blot out the sun!”

Snore. Can I get a dialogue that isn’t just people barking at each other, ostensibly to up the tension of the scene? Oh wait, the only times that happened I completely lost interest in the film because it was so tedious in contrast. This movie won awards. SEVEN OF THEM. HOW.

5. It’s war-porn

You know, I like fight scenes in my movies. I enjoyed the sweeping, panoramic battle vistas of Lord of the Rings, I admit to repeatedly rewatching anime fight scenes on YouTube, and I thoroughly enjoy the skirmishes in BtVS, Supernatural, Fight Club, etc. 300 completely turned me off due to the insanely creepy, almost overtly pornographic glee the film radiated during the fight scenes. There might as well have had a blinking APPLAUSE sign on the screen whenever a Persian soldier was brutally eviscerated; the Spartans get tragic music and mournful slow shots because they’re the good guys I guess.

6. It’s supposed to appeal to my (nonexistent) female chauvinism?

Remember the aforementioned oiled wall of rippling manflesh? According to most people, that should be everything I need to toss the previous five points out the window, sit back, and enjoy the soft-core pornography like everyone else apparently did. Yes, that’s right: the go-to defense of this movie is plain old sexism. Virgin/whore dialectic, eat your heart out – clearly there’s no middle ground between being frigidly unmoved by the male body and slaveringly objectifying Xerxes and his gold manties. No room for critical interpretation in the female brain, so ruled by our feelings are we (when not rigidly adhering to societal standards of propriety of course). Never mind that maybe I like a man who’s got a brain, who always speaks his mind; what I’m being told is to overlook the fact that I hate what he’s saying and focus on the physical. Do I look like Sansa Stark to you?

Fun game: what emotion is Michael Fassbender portraying in this still?

All in all, I walked out of the cinema kinda happy that they all died, completely rendering the hard work and actually pretty great work the actors put into their roles entirely moot. Thanks, 300. You really should not have been born.

  • http://www.fabledhorchata.blogspot.com Steena

    Thank you! The Oracle of Delphi was the only piece of this movie I needed to hate it (with a heavy emphasis on the fact that historical study shows that the Oracles were women past menopause) but I appreciate the full detailing of this movie’s failures. This movie, and presumably the graphic novel if it is true to its source, is war porn and porn porn for men. My least favorite argument in favor of this film is that the sex scene between Leonidas and Gorgo was “tastefully” done. *gag*

  • Allison

    I don’t think I hated this movie quite as much as you did, mostly I was just all “I don’t caaaaaare. Why is Lena Headey not in every single scene!?” 300 didn’t make me angry – it made me BORED. I mean, the ending was inevitable, there really was no plot to get to the ending, it was just miles and miles and miles of guys fighting. And I agree, I like the battles in LotR, and BtVS, but that’s because they included characters you had grown to love, not mindless war-crazed drones screaming nonsensically about how awesome they are.

    The plot, the dialogue, the character development, it was all crap. The only good thing about this movie was the technology that was used to make it – it was filmed in 60 days against a green screen. But as I said about Avatar, having awesome new technology just doesn’t matter if you make a crappy movie with zero plot or substance (okay Avatar did have a plot, but it was totally stolen from Pocahontas)

    And Ariel, I totally agree about the colonialist xenophobic war-propaganda issue with LotR. But at least LotR was MORE than just pure propaganda, at least LotR had characters and plot and substance. But yeah, definitely problematic.

    • Ariel Kroon

      LoTR was written to emulate northern European mythologies from a thousand years ago, and also was written during WWII by an older British gent and published in 1954-1955, so it at least has the excuse of literary traditions and historical ignorance.

      300 is history retold in the 21st century – they had the CHANCE to make it into a kickass, multilayered movie and totally dropped the ball on purpose. In fact, they threw that ball against the ground so hard it broke.

  • http://voguemademedoit.blogspot.ca/ Megan Patterson

    Oooh so my shirtless Fassie pic that is super popular on this site is from this movie, I think. I’ve blocked most of it out, I don’t even remember him being in it.
    I DO remember seeing at the theatres for some reason and getting in a fight with the people I went with over how terrible it is.

    • Ariel Kroon

      This movie is like, the thing that ruins cool people for me. I’ll bring it up, they’ll exclaim they love it, and I’ll have lost a goodly amount of of my esteem of them in like fifteen seconds flat :\

      • Elissa Smith

        I remember seeing it in theatres, being entertained enough to not think the night was a waste of time (I wasn’t paying, heh), and haven’t really felt the urge to see it again.

  • Elissa Smith

    As someone who does shamelessly fangirl over Fassbender… if you want to see him in something stupid, look up the music video where he turns into a goat. It’s as stupid as 300, but shorter. Also, goats.

    • Ariel Kroon

      See, that’s the problem. I don’t WANT to see him in something stupid. I want to see something intellectual that may include him at the same time.

      The stupidity of a movie – to my mind – reflects very poorly on the actors in said movie. :(